CGTrader commission: 40% on day one, years to reach 15%
CGTrader operates a tiered royalty system where your payout percentage increases as you accumulate lifetime sales. When you create a new account, you start at a 60% payout — meaning CGTrader keeps 40 cents of every dollar your models earn. The only way to increase your payout is to sell more.
| Lifetime sales | CGTrader payout | Platform cut |
|---|---|---|
| $0 – $249 | 60% | 40% |
| $250 – $499 | 65% | 35% |
| $500 – $1,499 | 70% | 30% |
| $1,500 – $4,999 | 75% | 25% |
| $5,000 – $9,999 | 80% | 20% |
| $10,000+ | 85% | 15% |
| Proofly — any amount | 100% | 0% |
The math is stark for new and mid-level creators. Selling a $20 model on CGTrader in the starter tier earns you $12. On Proofly it earns you $20. Across 100 sales, that's the difference between $1,200 and $2,000 — from the exact same model, the same buyers, the same effort.
CGTrader's exclusivity clause for premium products
CGTrader offers a separate "Exclusive" program for certain asset categories. Listing models as exclusive to CGTrader can increase your payout — but it means you cannot sell that model on any other platform simultaneously. If you later decide to move, you must remove it from CGTrader first.
Proofly never requires exclusivity. You can list the same model on Proofly and any other platform at the same time. Your catalog is your own — Proofly never locks you in.
3D viewer: CGTrader vs Proofly
CGTrader has a built-in 3D preview for many listings. However, the quality of the preview depends heavily on the original export: some formats render cleanly, others show material-stripping or geometry artifacts. Coverage is inconsistent — not every listing has an interactive preview, and some fall back to static renders.
CGTrader's viewer also does not show mesh quality information that matters to buyers deciding whether to purchase: polygon count, watertight status, bounding box dimensions, or per-format compatibility notes.
Proofly renders the actual file buyers will download, in-browser, with no plugin:
- ✓Solid / Wireframe / Clay / X-Ray / Normals modes — buyers inspect mesh topology before purchasing
- ✓Polygon count badge — shown live in the viewer corner for every model
- ✓Watertight check — “✓ Watertight” or “⚠ Non-watertight” badge so print buyers know before buying
- ✓Bounding box dimensions — switchable mm / cm / in; real scale, not just a render
- ✓2-point distance measure tool — click A→B on the mesh to measure any distance interactively
- ✓Animation playback — GLB and FBX animations play with speed control and timeline scrubber
- ✓Explode view — separates multi-part assemblies so buyers see every component
Piracy protection: what CGTrader doesn't do and what Proofly does
CGTrader delivers plain, unprotected files to every buyer. Once a model is downloaded, the file is byte-for-byte identical regardless of which buyer downloaded it. If a buyer reshares the file in a Discord server, Telegram group, or piracy forum, there is no mechanism on CGTrader to identify who the source was. You know your model was leaked; you don't know by whom.
This is the structural problem with every major 3D marketplace today — CGTrader, TurboSquid, MyMiniFactory, Cults3D, and others all have the same gap. A 3D mesh file format (STL, OBJ, GLB) has no native container for invisible persistent buyer identity.
Proofly solves this with HiddenMark™, a steganographic watermarking system that works at the mesh geometry level:
- 1When a buyer completes a purchase and downloads a file, Proofly embeds a unique per-transaction fingerprint into vertex position offsets in the mesh geometry — invisibly, below the threshold of visual perception
- 2The fingerprint survives re-export, re-slicing, and common mesh operations — it's in the geometry, not in file metadata
- 3If a file leaks, upload it to proofly.store/hiddenmark — HiddenMark reads the embedded fingerprint and returns the exact purchase record: buyer, model, transaction date
No creator action required — watermarks are embedded automatically at download time, invisibly, on every sale. HiddenMark is unique to Proofly. No other 3D marketplace currently offers per-buyer mesh-level fingerprinting.
Creator analytics: what you can actually act on
CGTrader provides basic listing statistics: view counts, download counts, and an overall sales total. It does not show you why a model gets views but no purchases, where your buyers come from geographically, which traffic source drives the most conversions, or whether your cover image is performing well.
Proofly's analytics dashboard is built around answering the question every creator actually has: “How do I increase sales without uploading more models?”
- ✓Conversion funnel — views → detail page opens → purchases, with drop-off % at each step per model
- ✓Traffic sources — organic search, direct, social, referral — broken out per model, not just platform-wide
- ✓Buyer geography — country breakdown with flags so you can see which markets buy your specific style
- ✓A/B thumbnail testing — upload two cover images; the dashboard shows live click-through rate for each
- ✓Actionable signals — “this model has 600 views but 0 purchases — try lowering price or improving the cover” surfaced automatically
- ✓Boost ROI — if you pay to boost a model in search results, the dashboard shows: views during boost, conversions, revenue generated, ROI
- ✓Category trend — “your category grew 18% this month” or “Game Assets is trending up — now is the time to upload”
File format support and buyer markets
CGTrader is strong in the game and visualization asset space — 3D Max, Maya, Blender source files, FBX, OBJ, and CAD formats are all common on the platform. Its buyer base skews toward game studios, architects, and visualization professionals.
Proofly serves both 3D printing and game/visualization markets, accepting and previewing a wide format set:
| Format | CGTrader | Proofly |
|---|---|---|
| STL | ✓ Upload + preview | ✓ Upload + WebGL + mesh analysis |
| OBJ + MTL | ✓ Upload + preview | ✓ Upload + textured WebGL preview |
| GLB / GLTF (PBR) | ✓ Upload + preview | ✓ Upload + full PBR material preview |
| FBX (with animations) | ✓ Upload + preview | ✓ Upload + animation playback + speed control |
| 3MF | Upload (limited preview) | ✓ Upload + WebGL preview |
| STEP / CAD | ✓ Upload + download | ✓ Upload + download |
| ZIP packages | Upload, extract manually | ✓ Auto-detect formats, per-file preview chips |
| MAX / MA / BLEND source | ✓ CGTrader-native formats | Upload + download (no preview) |
If your primary output is GLB / FBX game assets or STL print files, Proofly fully previews these formats. If you sell Blender or 3ds Max source files as your main product, you can still upload them to Proofly — buyers get the file, no preview — while the format preview on GLB exports works well as a visual demonstration alongside the source package.
CGTrader vs Proofly: full feature comparison
| Feature | CGTrader | Proofly |
|---|---|---|
| Commission | 15–40% (tier-based, 40% for new sellers) | 0% — keep 100% from sale one |
| Reaching best payout rate | $10,000+ in lifetime sales required | 100% from your first sale, always |
| Exclusivity requirement | Optional exclusive tier (locks model to CGTrader) | Never — list anywhere simultaneously |
| 3D viewer | Built-in for some formats, inconsistent quality | Full WebGL viewer for every listing, all formats |
| Mesh quality badge | No | Yes — watertight check, polygon count, dimensions |
| Piracy protection | None — plain unprotected files | HiddenMark™ per-buyer mesh watermark |
| Conversion analytics | Views + downloads, basic sales total | Full funnel, sources, geography, signals, A/B |
| A/B thumbnail testing | No | Yes — live CTR comparison |
| Boost / promoted listings | Editorial featured placements (not self-serve) | Self-serve boost with ROI tracking dashboard |
| Free model hosting | Yes | Yes |
| AI description generation | No | Yes — one-click AI title/description/tags/price |
| Payout method | PayPal, wire transfer | Stripe Connect (on-demand above threshold) |
Who benefits most from switching from CGTrader
Proofly is the strongest CGTrader alternative for creators in three situations:
New and growing creators
If you're just starting out, CGTrader's 40% commission at the starter tier means you lose almost half of every sale building their tier system. Proofly pays 100% from sale one — no graduation requirement, no tier system to climb.
3D printing model creators (STL, 3MF)
CGTrader's buyer base skews toward game/visualization buyers. Proofly has strong print market positioning with STL-specific features: watertight badge, per-mm dimension readout, slicer profile export (PrusaSlicer / Cura), and AI topology check on upload.
Creators worried about file leaks
If you've ever found your models reshared without authorization, HiddenMark™ solves the identification problem CGTrader and every other marketplace leaves open. Every Proofly download is fingerprinted — no extra steps, no cost.
How to list on Proofly alongside CGTrader
Because neither platform requires exclusivity, you don't have to remove anything from CGTrader. You can cross-list immediately:
- 1Export your source files — GLB, FBX, STL, OBJ, or a ZIP with multiple formats from Blender, ZBrush, Fusion 360, or wherever you work.
- 2Create a Proofly account at proofly.store/register — takes 60 seconds.
- 3Upload your models — drag-drop STL, GLB, or a ZIP. AI auto-generates description and tags from the mesh and filename; you review and adjust. The in-browser 3D viewer auto-generates a preview from the actual file.
- 4Set your price — same price you use on CGTrader is a reasonable starting point. You can use the AI price suggestion to see what comparable Proofly models sell for.
- 5Connect Stripe in dashboard settings for payouts — required to receive payments; Stripe Connect setup takes 5–10 minutes.
Your CGTrader listings stay active. Every sale on Proofly now goes entirely to you instead of losing 15–40% to the platform tier system.
Stop giving 15–40% of every sale to CGTrader
Proofly is the best CGTrader alternative for creators who want 0% commission from sale one, a built-in 3D viewer with mesh analysis, and per-buyer piracy tracing. Upload your first model free in 2 minutes.
Frequently asked questions
What commission does CGTrader take?
CGTrader uses a tiered royalty system starting at 60% payout (40% commission) for new sellers. The rate improves with lifetime sales: 65% after $250, 70% after $500, 75% after $1,500, 80% after $5,000, and 85% (top tier) after $10,000. Proofly charges 0% commission — you keep 100% of your listed price from your very first sale, with no tier system to climb.
Does CGTrader protect 3D files from piracy?
No. CGTrader delivers plain, unprotected files to every buyer. If a file is reshared after purchase, there is no way to identify which buyer caused the leak. Proofly's HiddenMark™ system embeds a unique per-buyer fingerprint in every download at the mesh geometry level. Upload a leaked file to proofly.store/hiddenmark to immediately see which purchase and which buyer it came from.
Can I sell on CGTrader and Proofly simultaneously?
Yes — neither platform requires exclusivity for standard listings. Many creators cross-list on both. The economics favor Proofly for earnings per sale: a $15 model sold 50 times earns $450 on CGTrader at the starter tier vs $750 on Proofly — from the same model, the same buyers, no extra work.
What 3D file formats does Proofly support?
Proofly supports STL (binary + ASCII with mesh analysis), GLB/GLTF with full PBR material preview, OBJ + MTL companion textures, FBX with animation playback, 3MF, STEP/CAD (download only), and ZIP packages (auto-detect + per-file preview chips). Blender .blend and 3ds Max .max source files can also be uploaded for download even though they don't have a live preview.
Does Proofly have a built-in 3D viewer like CGTrader?
Yes — Proofly has a full WebGL viewer on every listing that renders the actual file buyers download, with orbit/zoom/pan controls, wireframe/clay/X-ray/normals modes, polygon count badge, bounding box dimensions (mm/cm/in), a watertight check badge, 2-point distance measure tool, animation playback for GLB/FBX, and an explode view for multi-part assemblies.
What is the best CGTrader alternative in 2026?
Proofly is the strongest CGTrader alternative for creators who want to stop losing 15–40% of every sale to a platform tier system. Key advantages: 0% commission from sale one (vs CGTrader's 15–40%), HiddenMark™ per-buyer mesh watermarking for leak identification (unique to Proofly), a full-featured WebGL viewer with mesh analysis tools, and advanced analytics including conversion funnel, buyer geography, A/B thumbnail testing, and boost ROI tracking.