Skip to main content
vsHeroforge vs Proofly — physical minis vs printable STL files

Heroforge charges $7-25 per mini. Buy the STL file once and print unlimited.

Heroforge is a design-and-ship service: you customize a miniature and they mail you a physical plastic mini. At $7-25+ per order, reprinting costs the same every time. STL files on Proofly are a one-time purchase — buy the file for $3-10 and print it as many times as you want on your FDM or resin printer for a few cents in material per mini.

Cost to get 10 minis on the table

Heroforge physical prints vs STL files on Proofly printed at home

MethodPer mini10 minisReprint cost
Heroforge (plastic, standard)$7.99$79.90Same price again
Heroforge (premium plastic)~$15-25$150-250Same price again
Proofly STL + home resin printSTL ~$6 + $0.12 resin~$61.20 total$0.12 per reprint

Resin cost estimate: 3-4mL at $25/L. STL file is a one-time purchase; printer and resin are your only ongoing costs.

Side-by-side: Heroforge vs Proofly STL files

FeatureHeroforgeProofly STL files
What you getPhysical mini mailed to youSTL file — print as many as you want
Reprint costFull price again~$0.10-0.20 material cost only
Scale flexibilityFixed size per orderPrint at any scale in your slicer
Wait time7-14 days shippingInstant download — print in hours
Design customizationHeroforge editor (preset parts)Full STL — modify in Blender or Meshmixer
3D viewer before buyingIn-editor onlyFull WebGL — rotate, wireframe, X-ray, dimensions
Print quality controlHeroforge factory settingsYour printer, your settings, your quality level
Format compatibilityPhysical product onlySTL, 3MF — works in any slicer

Print at home: why STL files beat physical minis for most players

Heroforge is ideal if you want a custom character without owning a printer. But for players who already have an FDM or resin printer, buying STL files is dramatically cheaper per mini at scale. A resin printer (Elegoo Mars, Anycubic Photon) produces miniatures at roughly $0.10-0.20 in material — the resolution rivals Heroforge's standard plastic at a fraction of the ongoing cost.

Proofly's miniature and tabletop RPG categories include STL files for D&D monsters, fantasy heroes, terrain scatter, dungeon tiles, and wargaming units — all from independent creators. Each listing shows polygon count, bounding box dimensions, and manifold check results in the in-browser viewer so you know what you're printing before you buy.

For miniature creators: sell your STLs with piracy protection

If you design tabletop miniatures, Proofly lets you sell STL and 3MF files with HiddenMark protection — a unique steganographic watermark embedded in the mesh geometry of every paid download. If a buyer shares your file without authorization, you can upload the suspected file to proofly.store/hiddenmark and identify which purchase it came from in seconds.

Creators keep 100% of their listing price. The buyer pays a small flat service fee directly. You can list on Proofly alongside MyMiniFactory, Cults3D, and Printables with no exclusivity requirement.

HiddenMark watermarking

Every paid Proofly download gets a unique watermark in the mesh geometry — unique to the specific buyer and purchase. Invisible to slicers, renders, and editing software, but readable by the Proofly verifier. No other major miniature STL marketplace offers equivalent per-buyer forensic tracing.

How HiddenMark works →

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between Heroforge and an STL marketplace?

Heroforge is a custom miniature designer and print-on-demand service. You design a miniature in their browser tool, then they ship a physical mini to you — typically $7-25+ depending on material and size. You cannot reprint that mini without ordering again. An STL marketplace like Proofly sells you the 3D print file. You buy it once ($3-12 typically) and print it as many times as you want on your own FDM or resin printer, at a material cost of a few cents per mini.

Is Proofly a good alternative to Heroforge for tabletop miniatures?

Yes, if you own a 3D printer. Proofly's marketplace includes STL files for fantasy characters, D&D monsters, tabletop terrain, RPG props, and wargaming miniatures — all from independent creators. You download the STL file and print it yourself at whatever scale and quality your printer supports. You can reprint broken parts, scale figures to different sizes, and print multiple copies of the same mini without paying again.

How much does it cost to print miniatures from STL files?

With an FDM printer (PLA filament at ~$20/kg), a standard 32mm D&D miniature uses roughly 5-10g of filament — about $0.10-0.20 in material. With a resin printer (resin at ~$25/L), a 32mm mini uses 3-5mL — about $0.08-0.13 in resin. The STL file on Proofly costs a one-time $3-12 fee from the creator. Compare that to $7-25 per Heroforge physical mini, with no ability to reprint.

Do STL files from Proofly work with FDM and resin printers?

Yes. Proofly's STL files work with PrusaSlicer, Bambu Studio, Cura, Lychee Slicer, and Chitubox — the major slicing software for both FDM and resin printers. Many miniature creators on Proofly include print-tested profiles and recommended settings (layer height, supports, infill) in the listing. The in-browser 3D viewer lets you inspect topology and check for manifold geometry before buying.

Can I sell my own tabletop miniature designs on Proofly?

Yes. Proofly supports STL, 3MF, and OBJ uploads — the formats used for tabletop miniatures. Creators keep 100% of their listing price (the buyer pays a small flat service fee). Every paid download gets HiddenMark watermarking — a unique steganographic code in the mesh geometry that lets you identify any leaked file. You can sell on Proofly alongside MyMiniFactory, Cults3D, or other platforms with no exclusivity requirement.

Browse miniature STL files — print today

Instant download, full 3D preview before you buy, and HiddenMark protection on every file. Buy once, print unlimited.